Can fine discourage begging?
18 Star it
View Point , Shimla:
Aug 1 2009
Made Popular Aug 1 2009

Australia has decided to come hard on the begging. In order to do that, a town council in Australia’s Outback has proposed discouraging beggars by slapping them with a 130 Australian dollar. However, critics argued that such penalties could increase the need for panhandling. On the other, beggars already struggle to pay their bills with their welfare checks, which they receive every two weeks. Fining them would mean that they need to pay it from the welfare money; hence they would be left with no other mean but to beg again. So, is fining beggars a practical solution? How much would it help, if at all?
Add Images and Videos
Close X
Recommended Tags or Keywords
Search by Tags or Keywords
Selected Media ( You can Upload only Six media )
Sorry no picture found for this combination of tags. Try to search minimum number of tags at once
2 Stars
Agree
Nick
Aug 1 2009
Brisbane,
Australia
Only an insane person can agree to such solutions. The government should redress their problems out of which they are forced for begging.
Comment Link
1 Stars
Agree
Heavy fine should be imposed on the beggars. Government runs so many welfare sachems for the beggars despite of that they beg. I think such people have gone habitual of begging and imposing the fine seems to be good solution.
2 Stars
Disagree
Fining the beggars can never be a solution to the problem. Improving the living conditions of these people is the only way to get rid of this. Beggars are not so by choice but out of compulsion.
1 Stars
Disagree
Give them dignified means to earn their livelihood instead
1 Stars
Leena
That's the exact point. No one will prefer to beg if he/she gets the other respectable means to earn livelihood.
That's the exact point. No one will prefer to beg if he/she gets the other respectable means to earn livelihood.
1 Stars
Disagree
Some of the college professors around here have taken it as a case study to follow beggars and record their movements. Most finish their day of panhandling and crawl into $50,000 dollar SUVs and go home to $250,000 homes.
I know from my own naive experience, I tried to feed a few, they do not want food, they want cash!
There are many NGOs here that are fighting to capture their share of homeless, but they do not want to be helped, they refuse to go to the shelters.
Begging is big business and the ones who really need help often slip through the cracks.
I know from my own naive experience, I tried to feed a few, they do not want food, they want cash!
There are many NGOs here that are fighting to capture their share of homeless, but they do not want to be helped, they refuse to go to the shelters.
Begging is big business and the ones who really need help often slip through the cracks.
1 Stars
Begging is a business??? Then why Australian government is so eager to curb this business? It's not a business but it's a compulsion. We can get rid of this problem only by providing jobs to the beggars.
1 Stars
But Brajesh, begging has become a business to some extent even in India
1 Stars
Disagree
Like the bird circling the root of the problem is how the already rich prey on those that have little or no income. There is no balance, re: my article in the New Zealand Section Instablogs.com Greed and More Greed A Twisted dance by MP’s.
If a man does not have a sustainable income to buy food or pay rent what does that tell the world about a country.?
If a man does not have a sustainable income to buy food or pay rent what does that tell the world about a country.?
Local Opinions (9)
2 Stars
Agree
Only an insane person can agree to such solutions. The government should redress their problems out of which they are forced for begging.
1 Stars
Agree
Heavy fine should be imposed on the beggars. Government runs so many welfare sachems for the beggars despite of that they beg. I think such people have gone habitual of begging and imposing the fine seems to be good solution.
2 Stars
Disagree
Fining the beggars can never be a solution to the problem. Improving the living conditions of these people is the only way to get rid of this. Beggars are not so by choice but out of compulsion.
1 Stars
Disagree
Give them dignified means to earn their livelihood instead
1 Stars
Agree
Leena
That's the exact point. No one will prefer to beg if he/she gets the other respectable means to earn livelihood.
That's the exact point. No one will prefer to beg if he/she gets the other respectable means to earn livelihood.
1 Stars
Disagree
Some of the college professors around here have taken it as a case study to follow beggars and record their movements. Most finish their day of panhandling and crawl into $50,000 dollar SUVs and go home to $250,000 homes.
I know from my own naive experience, I tried to feed a few, they do not want food, they want cash!
There are many NGOs here that are fighting to capture their share of homeless, but they do not want to be helped, they refuse to go to the shelters.
Begging is big business and the ones who really need help often slip through the cracks.
I know from my own naive experience, I tried to feed a few, they do not want food, they want cash!
There are many NGOs here that are fighting to capture their share of homeless, but they do not want to be helped, they refuse to go to the shelters.
Begging is big business and the ones who really need help often slip through the cracks.
1 Stars
Agree
Begging is a business??? Then why Australian government is so eager to curb this business? It's not a business but it's a compulsion. We can get rid of this problem only by providing jobs to the beggars.
1 Stars
Disagree
But Brajesh, begging has become a business to some extent even in India
1 Stars
Disagree
Like the bird circling the root of the problem is how the already rich prey on those that have little or no income. There is no balance, re: my article in the New Zealand Section Instablogs.com Greed and More Greed A Twisted dance by MP’s.
If a man does not have a sustainable income to buy food or pay rent what does that tell the world about a country.?
If a man does not have a sustainable income to buy food or pay rent what does that tell the world about a country.?
Global Opinions (9)
2 Stars
Agree
Only an insane person can agree to such solutions. The government should redress their problems out of which they are forced for begging.
1 Stars
Agree
Heavy fine should be imposed on the beggars. Government runs so many welfare sachems for the beggars despite of that they beg. I think such people have gone habitual of begging and imposing the fine seems to be good solution.
2 Stars
Disagree
Fining the beggars can never be a solution to the problem. Improving the living conditions of these people is the only way to get rid of this. Beggars are not so by choice but out of compulsion.
1 Stars
Disagree
Give them dignified means to earn their livelihood instead
1 Stars
Agree
Leena
That's the exact point. No one will prefer to beg if he/she gets the other respectable means to earn livelihood.
That's the exact point. No one will prefer to beg if he/she gets the other respectable means to earn livelihood.
1 Stars
Disagree
Some of the college professors around here have taken it as a case study to follow beggars and record their movements. Most finish their day of panhandling and crawl into $50,000 dollar SUVs and go home to $250,000 homes.
I know from my own naive experience, I tried to feed a few, they do not want food, they want cash!
There are many NGOs here that are fighting to capture their share of homeless, but they do not want to be helped, they refuse to go to the shelters.
Begging is big business and the ones who really need help often slip through the cracks.
I know from my own naive experience, I tried to feed a few, they do not want food, they want cash!
There are many NGOs here that are fighting to capture their share of homeless, but they do not want to be helped, they refuse to go to the shelters.
Begging is big business and the ones who really need help often slip through the cracks.
1 Stars
Agree
Begging is a business??? Then why Australian government is so eager to curb this business? It's not a business but it's a compulsion. We can get rid of this problem only by providing jobs to the beggars.
1 Stars
Disagree
But Brajesh, begging has become a business to some extent even in India
1 Stars
Disagree
Like the bird circling the root of the problem is how the already rich prey on those that have little or no income. There is no balance, re: my article in the New Zealand Section Instablogs.com Greed and More Greed A Twisted dance by MP’s.
If a man does not have a sustainable income to buy food or pay rent what does that tell the world about a country.?
If a man does not have a sustainable income to buy food or pay rent what does that tell the world about a country.?
Agree (4)
2 Stars
Only an insane person can agree to such solutions. The government should redress their problems out of which they are forced for begging.
1 Stars
Heavy fine should be imposed on the beggars. Government runs so many welfare sachems for the beggars despite of that they beg. I think such people have gone habitual of begging and imposing the fine seems to be good solution.
1 Stars
Leena
That's the exact point. No one will prefer to beg if he/she gets the other respectable means to earn livelihood.
That's the exact point. No one will prefer to beg if he/she gets the other respectable means to earn livelihood.
1 Stars
Begging is a business??? Then why Australian government is so eager to curb this business? It's not a business but it's a compulsion. We can get rid of this problem only by providing jobs to the beggars.
Disagree (5)
2 Stars
Fining the beggars can never be a solution to the problem. Improving the living conditions of these people is the only way to get rid of this. Beggars are not so by choice but out of compulsion.
1 Stars
Some of the college professors around here have taken it as a case study to follow beggars and record their movements. Most finish their day of panhandling and crawl into $50,000 dollar SUVs and go home to $250,000 homes.
I know from my own naive experience, I tried to feed a few, they do not want food, they want cash!
There are many NGOs here that are fighting to capture their share of homeless, but they do not want to be helped, they refuse to go to the shelters.
Begging is big business and the ones who really need help often slip through the cracks.
I know from my own naive experience, I tried to feed a few, they do not want food, they want cash!
There are many NGOs here that are fighting to capture their share of homeless, but they do not want to be helped, they refuse to go to the shelters.
Begging is big business and the ones who really need help often slip through the cracks.
1 Stars
But Brajesh, begging has become a business to some extent even in India
1 Stars
Like the bird circling the root of the problem is how the already rich prey on those that have little or no income. There is no balance, re: my article in the New Zealand Section Instablogs.com Greed and More Greed A Twisted dance by MP’s.
If a man does not have a sustainable income to buy food or pay rent what does that tell the world about a country.?
If a man does not have a sustainable income to buy food or pay rent what does that tell the world about a country.?
Add your Comment
Home

Delicious
Digg
Facebook
Reddit
Stumble Upon
Technorati
Mixx
Sphinn
Twitter
SphereIt
Propeller
Gmarks
Newsvine
Yahoo! My Web
Live Journal
Blinklist
E-mail
RSS 











